Welcome to Benny's Pizza

At Benny’s Pizza, we keep it simple.

Great Food, Made Right, Every Time.

Located in Pleasant Valley, we’re proud to be a local spot where quality comes first.

From classic New York style pizza to fresh pastas, sandwiches, and house favorites, everything we serve is made with care.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite, feeding the family, or ordering for a big night, we’ve got you covered.

Order online for quick pickup or delivery, or stop in and see why Benny’s is Pleasant Valley’s go to spot!

Blurred Belgian waffle with white icing on a red checkerboard background

Close-up of colorful burgers on a grill rack

Cheesesteak pizza with beef, peppers, onions, and melted cheese

Pepperoni pizza with fresh basil on a cooling rack

Blurry close-up of cheesy pizza on red-and-white checkered paper

Freshly baked rectangular Italian pizzas on cooling racks

Garlic bread pieces with herb butter in a foil takeout tray

Glazed chicken wings served on a white plate

Online Ordering!

At Benny's Pizza, we offer a variety of delicious Pizzas, Pastas, Sandwiches, and more with a focus on quality and customer satisfaction. Our online ordering system makes it convenient for customers to place their orders and enjoy our food in the comfort of their own homes. We are committed to providing the highest level of excellence and ensuring all details are simple, seamless, and handled in a timely manner. Whenever you order from us, you can trust that you're in great hands.

Catering!

We offer catering services for your special events and occasions. We believe in using only the freshest ingredients and providing top-notch customer service. Explore our menu to learn more about our services and get in touch with us to discuss your catering needs.